These pages contain questions posted to our website and the answers we found for them.

We hope that these may be of use to you!

 

Home | Site Map | Contacts | Calendar | Help Files | Articles | Archives | Membership | Links | Library | Gallery | SwapShop

I am a new pond owner -- 6 months. Kalamazoo, MI. 780 gallons, non-filtered, but with 2 levels separated by a 2.5' rock waterfall and 4 ft streambed for aeration/filtration. 1 koi, 8-10 " by now, and 7 goldfish 3" - 6". 1 lotus, 2 water lilies, 1 pickerel rush, 1 parrot feather, 2 reeds in the short stream bed at the base of the waterfall, 2 huge taros and a couple of papyrus plants - the smaller kind upstairs. Water lettuce so healthy I've been culling and composting non-stop all summer. String alge, but nothing I can't live with. I may as well tell you I've never tested the water, though I have the chemicals to do it -- I have aquarium fish.

It is the best gardening I've ever done.

HOWEVER -- Those wretched goldfish spawned twice this summer and left me with what looked like (among all the plant life) literally 100s of fry.

QUESTION 1 -- How long would it take those babyfish to kill off my pond (i.e. other fish, plants), if I didn't do anything?

What I did to solve this problem (this might have been rash) was to catch a large-mouth bass of just-legal size (not big enough to eat the parental fish, although I have a couple of frogs I'm worried about) and introduce him to the pond.

QUESTIONS 2/3 -- Just how rash was that? Have I endangered my domestics?

The fry are gone, and I mean GONE after a week. My domestic fish, even the koi, who definitely has weight on the bass, if not length, are nervous and hiding behind the plants. They will come out and feed, but it takes them some time of me sitting there with the food floating. I have not seen the bass since I introduced him.

It seems obvious that I need to get the wild guy out, just to make the others happy. I thought about keeping him and giving him live bait for food, but that now seems like not such a good idea. But it does make me curious what other pond gardeners have done to control their goldfish population. I read the recommendation to pump into a pool, move your desireables, cull, etc. etc., but it seems just as stressfull to the fish and the plants as what I've done.

Context, observations, beratement, all would be welcome.

QUESTION 4 -- Is there an organization you are aware of that is closer to me than yours? are you a local or regional group?

majda



Hi, Majda! A common problem, and rather directly solved, though not quite as I'd have done it.

To answer your questions:

1) Your current pond has a ton of natural filtration, but your koi will stress it within the next two or three years as he grows. The zillions of goldfish would have done the same in one season if you had not thinned them out. Even a small biofilter in-line from your pump to the falls would give you a valuable cushion.

2/3) Not necessarily rash, just unwise in your choice of predator. Your koi and goldfish are telling you what they think of your choice. Bass are not only predators of fry, they are aggressive predators of any fish they can bully to death. They are also, as any sport fisherman can tell you, elusive little buggers. You'll have to get your goldfish and koi into a holding tank, drain your pond and isolate the bass in the deeper areas so you can net him out and put him back where he belongs. If you can save your pond water in a kiddie pond and pump it back in, your fish will thank you.

A better method of goldfish (and Koi) birth control would be Rosies, which are hell on itty-bits, but otherwise non-aggressive. They are good mosquito fish too. A single bluegill would also work, but they tend to be pretty aggressive, and I don't think I've ever seen a *single* bluegill.

4) Mick and Cathy Hodson run a large Koi and Garden club out of La Peer, MI. You can contact them at: cehodgso@hotmail.com

Bob Passovoy
President
MPKS


Back to Questions:   page 1 || page 2 || page 3 || page 4 || page 5 || page 6 || page 7 || page 8 || page 9