These pages contain questions posted to our website and the answers we found for them.

We hope that these may be of use to you!

 

Home | Site Map | Contacts | Calendar | Help Files | Articles | Archives | Membership | Links | Library | Gallery | SwapShop

Hi, I hope you can help me, because I've been trying to figure out if this is feasible, and I'd really appreciate your input.

I live in Iowa City, Iowa, and I have a (somewhat) large pond in my backyard. It is roughly 220 feet by 100 feet. It is in the remains of an old limestone quarry, and is fed in the winter by an underground spring at one end. The water has an average depth of 3 feet, with a deepest point about 10 feet.

Our house sits on the edge of the quarry, and we often spend time on the deck looking down at the fish in the pond. There is a very healthy (some HUGE) carp that live in the pond, and while I know koi arent the same thing as grass carp, I can't help imagine how beautiful they would be in this pond. I'm just trying to figure out if you think it would be possible to put fish in this pond. I'm not looking for any prize winning koi, but I believe that some pond quality koi would look really nice.

I'm sorry to bother you, but I've been doing lots of internet research, and I just havent found anything like this. I dont know if its because its not really possible, or just that no one has tried anything like this. If you could let me know what you think, I would really appreciate it.

Thank you very much,

Shawn Sato




Hey, Shawn!

What you have there, by midwest backyard ponding standards, is a *gigantonormous* pond with built-in filtration. It is what us urban-dwelling techno-driven hobbyists cry ourselves to sleep over every night. Doing a rough calculation, you've got about 600,000 gallons in there. I'd be amazed if there were not multiple other native species of fish in there as well as the grass carp, simply on the basis of egg transport in on the feathers and feet of the waterfowl that must be visiting on a regular basis.

If the water is replenished in the winter by a spring, I suspect that it is fed year-round. As long as the outlet does not feed a natural waterway, what you have there is technically the same as any other backyard pond, just a little (gulp) bigger and older. It is an artificial construct, with carp already in it.

Given that grass carp are a much tougher organism than koi, (not having been inbred for two hundred years) koi should survive fairly well in your back yard, with a couple of cautions. First, don't expect to see much of them. Unless your quarry water is gin-clear (which I doubt), you won't see *any* fish unless it is right up under your deck. When small, koi are "hard-wired" with "evade and run" in their teeny-tiny brains, and will tend to stay near the deeper parts of the water.

Grass carp and native fish are the colors they are for a reason. Camoflage. Koi are best described as "targets" under these circumstances, and any fishing bird worth his feathers (kingfishers, cormorants, bald eagles, herons, egrets, sandhill cranes) and every raccoon in the county will be coming over for lunch pretty soon, with koi at the top of the menu, simply because they are easy to see. This problem will be worsened if you feed them off your deck with floating food, since the koi will recognize any disturbance at the water's surface as something to eat, and will become part of the Great Circle of Life very quickly as a result.

Given that even "garden center" koi run $25-$50 dollars apiece, I don't think that it's a wise use of funds.


Bob Passovoy
President
MPKS

 

page 1 || page 2 || page 3 || page 4 || page 5 || page 6 || page 7 || page 8 || page9 || page 10 || page 11 || page 12 || page 13